Tennis Channel Files Petition For Full Court Review

Written by: on 16th July 2013
Tennis Channel Files Petition For Full Court Review  |

Tennis Channel has no plans to let its long time legal dispute with cable giant Comcast come to an end. The network filed a petition for full court review by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit of a three-judge panel decision in May that Comcast did not violate the FCC’s program carriage rules.

In that ruling, the court said Tennis Channel had not proved that Comcast had discriminated against it by not offering the network to all its subscribers as it does for other sports networks it owns, such as NBC Sports Network and the Golf Channel.

The ruling was a major blow to Tennis Channel, as it reversed a decision by the FCC that Comcast was by favoring its own networks over Tennis Channel and therefore harming it financially. The decision costs Tennis Channel millions in potential new subscriber revenue.

In its new petition, Tennis Channel stated that the ruling “departed from well-settled anti-discrimination law…ignored congressional intent and erroneously rejected extensive findings made by the FCC. Comcast’s programming business benefits from weakening the independent Tennis Channel’s ability to compete for programming and advertisers. This is exactly what Congress sought to prohibit when it adopted the Cable Act.”

Tennis Channel also argued that even though Comcast said its refusal to move it to a less expensive and more broadly distributed tier were for economic reasons, the FCC found that Comcast in fact made no effort to analyze the benefits its distribution business could obtain from Tennis Channel’s proposal for broader carriage.

Comcast has consistently contended they made a valid deal with Tennis Channel and that it received “exactly the carriage it bargained for and agreed to.”

Tennis Channel apparently wants the full court to rule on whether proof of economic loss due to discrimination is actually required.

Comcast countered:  “A unanimous panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals emphatically rejected Tennis Channel’s complaint in a well-considered opinion. We continue to treat Tennis Channel fairly, making it available to those customers who want it in full accordance with our contract.”

The case could drag on for another couple of years.

Cable industry watchers are paying close attention to it, as no carriage disputes of this type have advanced so far in litigation.

©Daily Tennis News Wire

Topics: , , , ,








10sBalls Top Stories

In Case You Missed It

EUGENIE BOUCHARD NAMED 2018 TENNIS CANADA FEMALE PLAYER OF THE YEAR / EUGENIE BOUCHARD NOMMÉE JOUEUSE DE L’ANNÉE 2018 DE TENNIS CANADA thumbnail

EUGENIE BOUCHARD NAMED 2018 TENNIS CANADA FEMALE PLAYER OF THE YEAR / EUGENIE BOUCHARD NOMMÉE JOUEUSE DE L’ANNÉE 2018 DE TENNIS CANADA

Tennis Canada announced on Wednesday that Eugenie Bouchard is the winner of the 2018 Excellence Awards in the Female Player of the Year and Singles Player of the Year categories.
TENNIS NEWS • CALIFORNIA CHAMPIONSHIPS • TOMMY HAAS, TAYLOR FRITZ, STEVE JOHNSON, MARDY FISH AND MORE thumbnail

TENNIS NEWS • CALIFORNIA CHAMPIONSHIPS • TOMMY HAAS, TAYLOR FRITZ, STEVE JOHNSON, MARDY FISH AND MORE

Time to get tickets to watch! Surly you have heard about The Largest Open Tennis Event in America!
TENNIS NEWS • RAFA NADAL CONFIRMS RETURN TO PRACTICE, EYES ABU DHABI EXHIBITION AND AUSTRALIAN SUMMER thumbnail

TENNIS NEWS • RAFA NADAL CONFIRMS RETURN TO PRACTICE, EYES ABU DHABI EXHIBITION AND AUSTRALIAN SUMMER

According to Uncle Toni, Rafael Nadal was supposed to be back at practice on either Dec. 4 or 5. Well, better late than never!
Conchita Martínez prepara la temporada 2019 de Karolina Pliskova en Tenerife thumbnail

Conchita Martínez prepara la temporada 2019 de Karolina Pliskova en Tenerife

Española y checa ya trabajaron juntas durante el pasado Open de Estados Unidos
ALEJANDRO’S FAVORITE PHOTOS FOR 10SBALLS FROM SOME OF THIS YEAR’S TOURNAMENTS thumbnail

ALEJANDRO’S FAVORITE PHOTOS FOR 10SBALLS FROM SOME OF THIS YEAR’S TOURNAMENTS

Jelena Ostapenko of Latvia hits a forehand to Kaia Kanepi of Estonia during her second round match at the Nature Valley International tennis tournament in Eastbourne, Great Britain, on Tuesday, June 26, 2018.