KRISTEN’S KOURT: THE TIEBREAK DEBATE
KRISTEN'S KOURT: THE TIEBREAK DEBATE
By Kristen Tracy
I’m pretty sure John Isner should start avoiding best of five matches against Frenchmen whose last name begins with “Ma.”
Watching today’s match between Isner and Paul Henri Mathieu at the French Open was painful. Not because it was a bad match, or because one player just slaughtered the other. In fact, it was the exact opposite. There was so much fight and heart coming from both players, which is exactly why watching it was so difficult. By the end of the match, both players looked like they could just collapse. I’m actually surprised either was able to walk off the court.
The match was everything a grand slam match should be. It was exciting, controversial (those French fans can be brutal), and full of incredible shots coming from both players. But as the match – and the fifth set – went on, I found myself just wanting it to end, regardless of the outcome.
The toll the match took on both Isner and Mathieu brings me to the ultimate point of this piece. For years, the US Open has been set apart from the other three grand slams for one big reason: it is the only major that allows a tiebreak in the fifth set. For tennis fans, the suspense of no tiebreak in the fifth set of match provides that much more excitement. If you’re a die-hard fan like I am, then you could probably sit and watch tennis 24/7 and still enjoy every second of it. But even I know there’s a line that can’t be crossed.
While I (and I’m sure everyone here at 10sballs.com) selfishly love the idea of no tiebreak in a fifth set, I know enough to know that it’s not good for the players. Let’s look back at Wimbledon 2010. Though John Isner fought for over 11 hours to win a first-round match, the toll it took on his body caused him to miss almost the entire summer leading up to the US Open – and even then he played his opening round with a seriously messed up ankle.
John McEnroe commented extensively today as the fifth set between Isner and Mathieu progressed, about how bad having no tiebreaker really is. Not only were both players on court for almost 6 hours but Mathieu, the victor of today’s battle, will have less than two days to rest before he is expected to go out and fight all over again. And I’d be very surprised if Isner tries to even practice anytime in the next week or so.
Not only did today’s marathon match cause trouble for the players on court, but Maria Sharapova and her opponent were forced to wait in the locker room for hours until their match was eventually cancelled and both players were sent home. It may not seem like a huge deal, but it causes not only an imposition on the players, but it also means that the winner of that match (presumably Sharapova) will have to play two days in a row at some point in the tournament.
Imagine being a player on the ATP tour and your match ends up going to a fifth set. Isn’t there a greater relief knowing that no matter what, it will be over in no more than 13 games? It has to be exhausting to just play and play, never knowing when the match will be over. As a fan, I find it incredibly stressful. As a player I’m sure it’s even worse. If you ask me, Melbourne, Paris, and London all need to take a page out of Flushing Meadows’ book and implement a fifth set tiebreaker – to save the sanity of the players, the fans, the media, and the game of tennis in general.
Follow Kristen on Twitter! @4theloveof10s
http://4theloveof10s.wordpress.com
Topics: 10sballs.com, French Open 2012, John Isner, Kristen Tracy, Kristen's Kourt, Paul Henri Mathieu, Roland Garros, Sports, Tennis
Share this article:
Follow 10SBALLS.COM on:
10sBalls Top Stories
- No Key Biscayne, No Problem; New Site, Same Great Miami Open Tennis Event
- 10SBALLS SHARES FAVORITE EPA TENNIS PHOTOS Of 2018
- THE PERFECT HOLIDAY GIFT FOR ANY TENNIS PLAYER & FAN
- ATP MEN’S TENNIS • WILL IT MOVE FROM LONDON TO MANCHESTER OR TOKYO OR SINGAPORE? OR TURIN?
- ALIX RAMSAY WRITES TO “TENNIS SANTA CLAUS” WITH HER WISHES • ANDY MURRAY!
- CALIFORNIA CHAMPIONSHIPS AT THE JACK KRAMER CLUB – DECEMBER 15 TO 22 2018 • UTR • ORACLE • AND AN AWESOME NEW TENNIS EVENT
- 10sBalls.com Shares Alix Ramsay’s Rambling On About Tennis and The Holidays
- ROGER FEDERER JOINED BY RAFA NADAL FOR THE 2019 LAVER CUP FESTIVITIES IN GENEVA, SWITZERLAND
- TENNIS PLAYERS’ UNION – IS IT NEEDED? BY MARK WINTERS
- Tennis News: Wilson’s Revolution Is Here – THE CLASH
- ROTTERDAM TENNIS TOURNEY DIRECTOR RICHARD KRAJICEK ANNOUNCES DAVID GOFFIN TO PLAY IN 2019 ABN AMRO
- JELENA VEMIC’S PHOTO GALLERY
- TENNIS NEWS FROM LONDON • 10SBALLS REPORTS ON THE LAWN TENNIS WRITERS HOLIDAY LUNCHEON AT WIMBLEDON’S DEBENTURE CLUB
- 10sBalls.com Shares a Great Gift For A Tennis Player – The Functional Tennis Match Journal
- BNP PARIBAS TENNIS OPEN NAMED 2018 WTA PREMIER MANDATORY TOURNAMENT OF THE YEAR FOR FIFTH STRAIGHT YEAR
In Case You Missed It
EUGENIE BOUCHARD NAMED 2018 TENNIS CANADA FEMALE PLAYER OF THE YEAR / EUGENIE BOUCHARD NOMMÉE JOUEUSE DE L’ANNÉE 2018 DE TENNIS CANADA
Tennis Canada announced on Wednesday that Eugenie Bouchard is the winner of the 2018 Excellence Awards in the Female Player of the Year and Singles Player of the Year categories.
TENNIS NEWS • CALIFORNIA CHAMPIONSHIPS • TOMMY HAAS, TAYLOR FRITZ, STEVE JOHNSON, MARDY FISH AND MORE
Time to get tickets to watch! Surly you have heard about The Largest Open Tennis Event in America!
TENNIS NEWS • RAFA NADAL CONFIRMS RETURN TO PRACTICE, EYES ABU DHABI EXHIBITION AND AUSTRALIAN SUMMER
According to Uncle Toni, Rafael Nadal was supposed to be back at practice on either Dec. 4 or 5. Well, better late than never!
Conchita Martínez prepara la temporada 2019 de Karolina Pliskova en Tenerife
Española y checa ya trabajaron juntas durante el pasado Open de Estados Unidos